Bobby Jindal wrote an op-ed on health care for the Wall Street Journal. He notes the way Hillary Clinton’s health care plan failed because it was negotiated behind closed doors without input from all sides of the debate and that it was a “philosophical over-reach.” President Obama is making the same mistakes. The dishonest approach is necessary or they won’t produce the desired results. The three biggest lies of the democrats:
First, Mr. Obama doggedly promises that if you like your (private) health-care coverage now, you can keep it. That promise is hollow, because the Democrats’ reforms are designed to push an ever-increasing number of Americans into a government-run health-care plan.
If a so-called public option is part of health-care reform, the Lewin Group study estimates over 100 million Americans may leave private plans for government-run health care. Any government plan will benefit from taxpayer subsidies and be able to operate at a financial loss—competing unfairly in the marketplace until private plans are driven out of business. The government plan will become so large that it will set, rather than negotiate, prices. This will inevitably lead to monopoly, with a resulting threat to the quality of our health care.
Second, the Democrats disingenuously argue their reforms will not diminish the quality of our health care even as government involvement in the delivery of that health care increases massively. For all of us who have seen the Federal Emergency Management Agency’s response to hurricanes, this contention is laughable on its face. When government bureaucracies drive the delivery of services—in this case inserting themselves between health-care providers and their patients—quality degradation will surely come. House Democrats seem willing to accept that problem to achieve their philosophical aim—the long-term removal of for-profit entities from the health-care landscape.
Third, Mr. Obama’s rhetoric paints a picture of a massive new benefit that will actually cost average Americans less than what they pay today. The Democrats want middle-class taxpayers to believe they won’t feel the pinch of this initiative, even as their employers are assessed massive new taxes. They might as well try to argue that up is down. The analysis of the Democrats’ proposal by the Congressional Budget Office shows that it will not reduce government spending on health care, and that it will substantially increase the federal deficit—and this despite all the tax increases.
Jindal goes on to outline seven common sense principles of health care reform which must be adhered to if we want to bring down the cost of medical care in America. The list includes tort reform, insurance reform, small business pooling, consumer choice, and refundable tax credits.
If President Obama wanted true health care reform (as opposed to government controlling our health) he would sit down and listen to all ideas. I guess that’s just not on his agenda.
