Despite costing taxpayers $180 billion since it’s inception, the federal early childhood education program Head Start is a big flop. What a surprise.
There’s just one problem: It doesn’t work.
Until recently, no one even conducted a scientific test of Head Start’s effectiveness. Republicans demanded one in 1998, and the Department of Health and Human Services commissioned it four years later. The ongoing randomized study of Head Start was based on a nationally representative sample of 5,000 children who applied for the program in 2002. Approximately half of the subjects received Head Start services, while the other half did not. The students were then tested on their language, literacy, math and school performance skills.
The initial results were supposed to be published by the HHS in March 2009. But the Obama administration delayed this until January 2010, at which point the reason became obvious. As the 2010 Head Start Impact Study report notes, “the benefits of access to Head Start at age four are largely absent by 1st grade for the program population as a whole.” Specifically, the language, literacy, math and school performance skills of the Head Start children all failed to improve. (Read More)
A follow up study didn’t produce better results. But don’t expect this program to come to an end. Liberals love it, it makes them feel good, at our expense. Seeing the way things are going these days they’ll probably expand it, they want nothing more than getting to our children when they’re really young. Even the massive pork-laden Sandy relief bill that passed in the House had money included for this failed program.


Just think: This was the shining light of El Beejay’s War on Poverty, his “Great Society” spending spree. If this was the best,just think how great the rest of the thing was.
Like or Dislike:
1
Not to mention what involvement with Head Start means to personal freedoms. Our daughter, who lives in a rural NY town, decided to send our grandson to Head Start so he could learn to play with others. Our daughter is a stay at home mom whose husband earns barely enough to keep them off public assistance. My grandson had attended for about two weeks when she recieved a notice that the program would be conducting an in-home visit to screen for obesity and low small motor skills. When my daughter called me with grave concerns about this, I simply told her that if she wished to use free government programs she should be prepared for government intervention into her life and her childrens lives. She immediately pulled our grandson out of Head Start and learned a very important lesson about entitlement along the way. We are very proud that she has opted to stay home and take care of her children while finding ways to be independent from government hand outs. And, oh, the “curriculum” at his Head Start program consisted of playing with others, no ABCs no 123s, no instruction of any material. Why this program remains high on the list of must-haves is beyond me.
Like or Dislike:
2
Shocka! Taking young toddlers away from their moms and putting them in a room full of strangers doesn’t make those kids emotionally healthy or better educated! Whoda thunk it?
Here’s another shocka: very young children do not do as well in daycare as they do when they have a full time loving parent either.
Like or Dislike:
2